No one man is goodlooking to everybody. BUT there are those who are considered goodlooking generally even when matured or fat or slim. It is not subjective to most people and in most cases.
BUT then there are those considered cmi no matter how you try not to be judgmental. I remember seeing an extremely ugly man posting his pics on Facebook (for those who say this is subjective maybe I'll post his pic later to show that some cmi is not subjective). Yet, he was posting selfies of himself and acting cute. OMG, no matter how you try to be kind he is damn ugly. I felt like telling him the truth on his comment page.
But strangely, I see 3 to 4 comments from his followers telling him he is hot??? Wow, even gollum can be prince charming to some. But looking at those followers, omg they are only slightly better than him.